5 min read

Reflections on Kentucky’s 2023 Legislative Session: Causes for Concern & Celebration

Reflections on Kentucky’s 2023 Legislative Session: Causes for Concern & Celebration
Written by
The Prichard Committee
Published on
May 12, 2023

With the 2023 Legislative Session behind us, Kentucky’s continued decline in education outcomes continues to sound alarm bells for our future. In just the last decade Kentucky has fallen to:

  • 29th in the nation fourth-grade reading — a fall from 22nd in 2019 and a high of 8th in the nation in 2015,
  • 28th in the nation in eighth-grade reading — a drop from 25th in 2019 and a peak at 12th in 2011,
  • 34th in the nation in fourth-grade math — a fall from 30th in 2019 and 21st in 2015,
  • and 41st in the nation in eighth-grade math — down from 36th in 2019 after reaching 33rd in the nation in 2011.

Despite Kentucky’s downward slump in education outcomes, the Prichard Committee celebrates the steps taken by the 2023 Kentucky General Assembly to return Kentucky to a place where education outcomes are improving.

Particularly, steps taken in the following successful pieces of legislation move the needle in providing a Big Bold Future for all Kentuckians:

  • House Bill 319, An act relating to teacher shortages, sponsored by House Education Chairman James Tipton (R-53);
  • Senate Bill 156, An act relating to a statewide reading research center, sponsored by Senate Education Chairman Stephen West (R-27);
  • Senate Bill 70, An act relating to relating to a pilot program for performance-based professional development, sponsored by Senate President Pro Tempore David Givens (R-09); and
  • Senate Joint Resolution 98, A resolution directing the Council on Postsecondary Education to study the placement and services provided by public universities and community and technical colleges in the Commonwealth, sponsored by Senate President Robert Stivers (R-25).

Take a look at each of the pieces of legislation below, where we break down the details and explain how they can help provide a Big Bold Future for all Kentuckians.

House Bill 319, An act relating to teacher shortages, sponsored by House Education Chairman James Tipton (R-53)

Chairman Tipton’s House Bill 319 is designed to address Kentucky’s teacher shortage. The bill is divided into four policy items:

I. Interstate Teacher Mobility Compact

The Interstate Teacher Mobility Compact is like a shortcut for teachers who want to work in a different state. It makes it easier for them to get their license and move to a new state to teach. The idea is to support teachers by providing them with a new pathway to licensure that enhances their ability to move across state lines.

Policy Goals:

  • Enhance the power of state and district level education officials to hire qualified, competent teachers by removing barriers to the employment of out-of-state teachers,
  • Create a streamlined pathway to licensure mobility for teachers,
  • Support the relocation of eligible military spouses,
  • Facilitate and enhance the exchange of teacher licensure, investigative, and disciplinary information between the member states,
  • Support the retention of teachers in the profession by removing barriers to re-licensure in a new state, and
  • Maintain state sovereignty in the regulation of the teaching profession.

To learn more about the Interstate Teacher Mobility Compact, read more here from EdWeek.

II. Exit Surveys for School Personnel Leaving Employment

To help with teacher recruitment and retention, teachers or other school personnel will be asked to complete an exit survey when they leave their job voluntarily. The survey responses will be anonymous. To keep track of the data, KDE will create a system for reporting the survey results.

Policy Goals:

Information submitted by an employee and reported to the department includes:

  • the position vacated,
  • the employee’s years of service in the position and in the district,
  • if the employee is taking a similar position in another district,
  • and the reason or reasons provided for leaving the district.

III. Kentucky Educator Placement Service System

The Kentucky Educator Placement Service System is an online job board run by the KDE for local school districts and public charter schools. It lets job seekers apply online for open positions and upload their application materials. School districts and public charter schools can then access and download these applications. Local districts can also have their own job boards in addition to the statewide platform run by KDE.

Policy Goals:

  • The Kentucky Department of Education shall operate and maintain the system to ensure:
    • that job postings are current, including tracking each unique position posted,
    • monitored for repeated position postings,
    • outdated postings are removed,
    • and that accurate data is collected about employment in public schools.
  • KDE shall prepare a report detailing data from the system and its implications for the status of employment in public schools including:
    • the number and type of unique and duplicate job postings,
    • how often postings are viewed by the public,
    • and positions that are remaining vacant by type, certification requirement, and location.
    • The report shall be submitted to the Interim Joint Committee on Education each year.

IV. Technical Changes to Kentucky Teacher Scholarship Program

Changes include:

  • A drop to 8% interest rate for repayment purposes, down from 12%.
  • A requirement for the scholarship authority to:
    • submit a report on the number of teacher scholarships provided in each fiscal year,
    • the program of study in which recipients are enrolled,
    • recipient retention rates,
    • total number of applications, and
    • reporting of scholarship recruitment strategies to the Interim Joint Committee on Education.
  • A process for candidates to obtain an eligible for hire letter from the Education Professional Standards Board, should the certification option require employment prior to certification.

Senate Bill 156, An act relating to a statewide reading research center, sponsored by Senate Education Chairman Stephen West (R-27)

Chairman Stephen West’s Senate Bill 156 is designed to establish a statewide reading research center. The center will support educators in implementing evidence-based reading programs. The legislation builds upon Senator West’s successful passage and implementation of the Kentucky Read to Succeed Act in 2022.

I. Purposes of Statewide Reading Research Center

The center is designed to support educators in implementing reading programs that are:

  • Reliable
  • Replicable, and
  • Evidence-based

II. Collaboration between the Center and Kentucky Department of Education (KDE)

  • The Center and KDE will set annual goals and performance objectives and report on the effects of those activities on state performance levels in reading and writing, and the outcomes of all annual goals and performance objectives.
  • Based on the annual outcomes, KDE will make programming and funding recommendations to the Governor, the Legislative Research Commission (LRC), and the Interim Joint Committee on Education by October 1 of each year.
  • Additionally, KDE will select the administrator of the statewide reading research center for approval by the Kentucky Board of Education (KBE). The selected administrator will be contracted for 5 years unless funding is not available.

Senate Bill 70, An act relating to a pilot program for performance-based professional development, sponsored by Senate President Pro Tempore David Givens (R-09)

President Pro Tempore David Givens’ Senate Bill 70 permits teachers in local school districts the ability to develop and implement a performance-based professional development project designed to produce measurable outcomes of positive impact on student performance.

I. Program Requirements

The pilot program requires 2 or more teachers to design an instructional practice or strategy project to address a school or district academic or nonacademic classroom problem. The program will run from the 2023-2024 school year to the 2025-2026 school year.

Successful completion of a project under this section shall satisfy up to 3 days of the requirement to complete 4 days of professional development.

A local board of education may award a teacher a stipend for successful completion of a project.

II. Local Board of Education Responsibilities

Local boards of education determine the following:

  • Project application process.
  • Review and approval of project proposals.
  • Submission of completed project analysis and results.
  • Evaluation of completed projects.
  • The awarding of professional development credit, including the amount of the credit and when it will be credited.
  • The awarding of a stipend, if applicable.

Additionally, KDE will study the completed pilot projects for their impact on schools and districts to determine the attributes of quality performance-based professional development and the best practices for measuring its effectiveness.

Senate Joint Resolution 98, A resolution, sponsored by Senate President Robert Stivers (R-25)

Senate President Robert Stivers’ Joint Resolution 98 directs the Council on Postsecondary Education (CPE) to study placements and services provided by public universities and community and technical colleges. The President of the Council on Postsecondary Education will report the study with findings and recommendations by December 1, 2023.

The resolution directs CPE to undertake the following actions:

  • Study the projected needs of the state over the next 20 years in terms of postsecondary education attainment, workforce, and economic needs.
  • Provide recommendations on changes needed to the state’s postsecondary governance structure that would be essential to meet identified needs and ensure the best delivery of postsecondary educational services to students.
  • Study the impact and feasibility of establishing a regional, residential, four-year public university in southeastern Kentucky.
  • Study the feasibility of having the Kentucky Community and Technical College System (KCTS) continue to be responsible for technical education programs but transfer responsibility for traditional academic subjects to the regional universities.

While much work remains in the mission to return Kentucky to a place where education outcomes are improving, The Prichard Committee applauds these positive steps forward championed by Representative Tipton, Senator West, Senator Givens, and Senate President Stivers.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay up to date with our work.

By subscribing, you consent to receive updates from The Prichard Committee.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Recent posts

Kentucky Test Scores Show Slight Improvement
5 min read

Kentucky Test Scores Show Slight Improvement

Kentucky has seen improvement in four of the measures that the Prichard Committee most closely tracks.

Oct. 3, 2024

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Contact: Lisa McKinney

lisa@prichardcommittee.org

(cell) 859-475-7202

Kentucky Test Scores Show Slight Improvement

Community Accountability Necessary to Quicken the Pace

A statement from Brigitte Blom, President and CEO

LEXINGTON, Ky -- In the new public school learning results data released today by the Kentucky Department of Education, Kentucky has seen improvement in four of the measures that the Prichard Committee most closely tracks. Compared to 2023, the new data release shows:

  • A 2% increase in the kindergarten readiness of students entering school last fall
  • A 1% increase in grade 3 students scoring proficient or above in reading
  • A 1% increase in grade 8 mathematics proficiency
  • A 1% increase in the four-year high school graduation rate

There was no progress on two other priority measures:

  • No increase in grade 3 mathematics proficiency
  • A 3% decline in grade 8 reading proficiency

Even the measures that have improved remain far from Kentucky’s long-term goals. For example, only 47% of 2024 third-grade students were proficient or above in reading. If we continue improving at a pace of 1% each year, it could take 53 years to get all Kentucky students to the proficient level in that foundational subject.The results released today also confirm the urgency of Kentucky’s work to ensure that students of all backgrounds thrive in our schools:

  • Even as grade 3 reading proficiency rose overall, it declined for English learners and for students with disabilities and showed no improvement for economically disadvantaged students and Hispanic or Latino students.  
  • Grade 8 math results also rose overall, but showed no improvement for African American, Hispanic or Latino students and English learners. In slightly better news, economically disadvantaged students and students with disabilities did see grade 8 mathematics improvement that was a bit stronger than that of their classmates.
  • The other indicators provide similar evidence that we have not yet moved beyond our historic failures in closing achievement gaps.

The Prichard Committee will be doing further analysis on postsecondary readiness. It is difficult to compare this year’s 81% readiness rate directly to last year’s 79% rate, because this is the first year that readiness includes students who have been successful in work-based learning. While including that data going forward is beneficial, our analysis will need to consider how it affects year-to-year comparisons. We are also concerned to see that the percent of students reaching ACT benchmarks has declined and look forward to studying those patterns in more depth. If graduation rates remain steady or increase while postsecondary readiness measures decrease, that raises questions about how meaningful Kentucky’s high school diplomas are for preparing students for post-graduation life.

In response to today’s new data, the Prichard Committee urges Kentuckians in every community to review the results and develop new local efforts to ensure that our public schools offer all learners the full opportunities and supports they need to flourish. As a starting point, communities can work together on active family and community engagement, expanded and enriched learning times, integrated supports, and collaborative leadership and practices to support high-quality teaching.

The Prichard Committee also urges stronger state-level policy efforts and financial investments in our public schools. The new LETRS (Read to Succeed) program is off to a promising start, and added funding for kindergarten and school transportation are important starting points, but we need to do more as a commonwealth. Kentucky must deepen our efforts on teaching quality, working conditions, and shortages, and we must strengthen state SEEK funding, including meeting full transportation costs. Now is the time to invest appropriately in public education and ensure public dollars are not being diverted from the public schools that educate the vast majority of Kentucky students.

Overall, Kentucky’s future demands renewed and strengthened commitment to public schools that can equip each and every graduate has the durable skills and the depth of knowledge to succeed as adult learners, as workforce participants, and as contributors to our communities. It is every community members’ responsibility to help build a Big, Bold Future for the commonwealth with education at its core. Let’s get to work.

2024 SNAPSHOTS OF KENTUCKY K-12 RESULTS
5 min read

2024 SNAPSHOTS OF KENTUCKY K-12 RESULTS

This morning, the Kentucky Department of Education released important Kentucky State Assessment (KSA) results...

This morning, the Kentucky Department of Education released important Kentucky State Assessment (KSA) results and other indicators that matter for our public schools. As an added way to see some of the major patterns in that data, the Prichard Committee has created a 2023-24 Snapshot approach to statewide elementary school, middle school, and high school data and showing:

  • The statewide percent of students who scored proficient or distinguished in reading, mathematics, science, social studies, and writing on the 2023 KSA
  • Results for all students, for students who are and are not identified as English learners, for students with and without identified disabilities, for students with and without economic disadvantage, for students in seven groups by race and ethnicity, and for female and male students
  • A single page display for elementary school results and for middle school results
  • A two page display for high school results, with one page for KSA and another for ACT results, graduation rate, and postsecondary readiness rate

Unsurprisingly, the results shows that we have important work ahead to reach 100% proficiency and readiness, and they continue to show differences in how well we are serving students with different backgrounds and needs. For example, here’s a quick look at elementary school reading results, combining grades 3,4, and 5.

If we engage this data with candor and concern, it can strengthen our work to ensure that all Kentucky learners are welcome, respected, and empowered in our public schools.

As communities and as a commonwealth, we need public schools to equip every student in our rising generation to play a full role in Kentucky’s Big Bold Future.

Please do take a look at the new Snapshot data for each level.

The Prichard Committee releases analysis of ‘school choice’ Amendment 2
5 min read

The Prichard Committee releases analysis of ‘school choice’ Amendment 2

The Prichard Committee for Academic Excellence today released an analysis of Amendment 2

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Aug. 20, 2024

Contact: Lisa McKinney

(cell) 859-475-7202

lisa@prichardcommittee.org

The Prichard Committee releases analysis of ‘school choice’ Amendment 2

Committee issues statement of opposition to the amendment

(LEXINGTON, Ky) --The Prichard Committee for Academic Excellence today released an analysis of Amendment 2, a proposed amendment to Kentucky’s Constitution that would allow the allocation of public funds to school choice options beyond traditional public schools. The analysis, which outlines the potential financial and education outcomes of the amendment, found that funding private K12 educational institutions is not an appropriate or effective use of public funds.  

Amendment 2 will appear on ballots in November.  

“An amendment to Kentucky’s constitution that opens the door to private school choice with public dollars is likely to have significantly negative consequences for Kentucky’s long-standing march to improve education outcomes,” said Prichard Committee President/CEO Brigitte Blom. “Diverting public dollars to private school choice options creates the conditions for an unregulated market with no accountability to the taxpayers who fund it, and no durable research that warrants such an investment.”

The amendment's passage would allow the legislature to direct public funds to support private schools (including parochial schools), homeschooling, and charter schools through various financial mechanisms like vouchers, tax credits and education savings accounts.

Diverting funds to private schools is shown to spread scarce resources across more providers, thereby reducing overall access and improvement to quality in education, especially in areas where there is population decline. This will certainly be true in rural areas of the state and could likely be true for the state as a whole with population decline forecasted in the years to come.  

Additionally, Amendment 2 would open the door to the state investing in education options that create barriers for accountability. Public schools are held to accountability standards of which private and parochial schools, as well as homeschools, are currently exempt.    

Research shows that in states with high participation in school choice programs, a significant portion of funds frequently benefit wealthier families, leaving low- and middle-income families with less funding for the public schools these families rely on. Ensuring public funds stay within the public education system supports a fair distribution of resources to help ensure better outcomes for all students, the analysis found.  

Additionally, public schools are required to serve all students, including those with disabilities and the need for additional support. Many private schools are not required to guarantee the same level of support for students with learning differences, and the requirement to serve all children falls back to the public system, with fewer resources.

“Investing state dollars in what works is critical, and even more so in a state like Kentucky where we've risen from the bottom of the national rankings since the 1990s to roughly the middle today,” said Blom. “While there is clearly more work to be done to continue to improve education outcomes - and parents can and must demand that improvement - now is not the time to spend shared public dollars on strategies with no durable outcomes at best - and negative outcomes at worst.”  

Read the Prichard Committee’s full analysis here.